Bad appraisal following maternity leave: ask the expert 

I returned to work full time six months ago following eight months of maternity leave. I didn’t have a return to work interview and have never had an appraisal. After three months, my job was made redundant, but I was redeployed to a new role which started this month. I had my first appraisal today with the CEO who, after asking how long I’d been in the post prior to taking maternity leave (13 months), told me that the period I’d been away had caused a ‘setback’ to achieving real change in my department. He then went on to appraise the person who was my maternity cover in a positive way and said that my return had marked a return to ‘business as usual’ and a ‘cliquey operation’. I’ve had regular one to ones with this manager who previously praised my ‘raised energy levels’ and had not indicated there were any issues to be concerned about. Is what he said ‘discriminatory behaviour’?
 The CEO’s comment that your period of maternity leave had been a ‘set back’ to achieving real change in your department is clearly discriminatory and this comment should not have been made. However, this comment on its own is unlikely to be sufficient for you to succeed with a claim for sex discrimination and/or constructive dismissal.
Furthermore, I understand that the CEO then stated to the person who was your maternity cover that your return had marked a return to ‘business as usual’ etc – i.e. positive comments in respect of your return to work.
Therefore, looking at the entire picture, I would not advise you at this stage to take any action. However, you should keep a written record of dates and details of any unfavourable comments made regarding your maternity leave and if further negative comments are made, you may potentially have a claim against your employer for sex discrimination and/or constructive dismissal.
In relation to the CEO’s comment regarding your period of maternity leave being a set back for the department, you could raise either an informal grievance or formal grievance in writing to your employer. However, this may blow matters out of proportion and you need to consider this.




Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *